Traumatic Critique, Secrets of Strixhaven #358

Buy this card

3,10 €34,03 kr · $3.46

non-foil · NM/LP · ships from Sweden · foil from 4,40 €

In stock cards ship within 2 days. Others are sourced for you from European sellers after payment and ship within 7–14 days; the exact price is confirmed in the cart. Postage from 2,90 € in Sweden (tracked from 30,00 €), free above 300,00 €. Minimum order 15,00 €. We send NM when the price is close; the exact condition is shown in the cart.

We buy this card

0,10 €1,10 kr · $0.11 cash · NM

LP 0,00 € · MP 0,00 € · foil NM 0,30 € · up to 4 copies

Sell it to us

Scan the card with your phone, send it in, get paid by bank or Swish. Offer fixed for 7 days once you submit your list.

Traumatic Critique

Instant · {X}{U}{R} · EDHREC #8173

Secrets of Strixhaven · #358 · rare · 2026-04-24 · nonfoil, foil · art by Aaron Miller

1,11 €12,19 kr · $1.24market, Cardmarket trend-13.9%30d

Outlook 30 days

-4.5%

Value score

58/100

Likely range in 30d

0,73 € – 1,39 €

high confidence · trend falling

+3.7%

30d

-13.9%

90d

-14.6%

From 90d high

-35%

Dealers pay

18% of retail

Reprint risk

near the usual 6-month low

Standard arc: in Standard · leaves Standard 2029-02-01 (819 days)

Price history (EUR)

dealer buylists

Marketplace prices

Marketplace	List	Finish	Native	EUR · SEK · USD	As of
Cardmarket	retail	foil	2,23 €	2,23 €24,48 kr · $2.49	2026-11-04
Cardmarket	retail	normal	1,11 €	1,11 €12,19 kr · $1.24	2026-11-04
Card Kingdom	buylist (cash offer)	foil	$0.63	0,56 €6,19 kr · $0.63	2026-11-02
Card Kingdom	buylist (cash offer)	normal	$0.23	0,21 €2,26 kr · $0.23	2026-11-04
Card Kingdom	retail	foil	$2.49	2,23 €24,47 kr · $2.49	2026-11-04
Card Kingdom	retail	normal	$1.79	1,60 €17,59 kr · $1.79	2026-11-04
Mana Pool	retail	foil	$0.40	0,36 €3,93 kr · $0.40	2026-11-04
Mana Pool	retail	normal	$0.31	0,28 €3,05 kr · $0.31	2026-11-04
TCGplayer	retail	foil	$1.43	1,28 €14,05 kr · $1.43	2026-11-04
TCGplayer	retail	normal	$1.23	1,10 €12,09 kr · $1.23	2026-11-04

Card text and legality

Traumatic Critique deals X damage to any target. Draw two cards, then discard a card.

Legal in: standard, future, historic, timeless, gladiator, pioneer, modern, legacy, vintage, commander, oathbreaker, standardbrawl, brawl, competitivebrawl, alchemy, duel, tlr

Scryfall

All printings of Traumatic Critique (3)

Set	#	Rarity	Released	Cardmarket €	TCGplayer $	Shop
Secrets of Strixhaven SOS	239	rare	2026-04-24	0,69 €	$0.57	2,60 €28,54 kr · $2.90
Secrets of Strixhaven Promos PSOS	239p	rare	2026-04-24	0,54 €	$0.55	2,50 €27,45 kr · $2.79
Secrets of Strixhaven SOS	358	rare	2026-04-24	1,11 €	$1.23	3,10 €34,03 kr · $3.46